Photo Montage

fatih · 01-20-2007

good tutorial: http://youtube.com/watch?v=shWVvC1MvSA

**Tamlin** · 01-22-2007

This is not a "tutorial". A tutorial is a teaching aid. This is a speeded-up video of someone working in Photoshop with a cheesy musical soundtrack. No instruction, no explanations, nothing.

fatih · 01-23-2007

Quote:

Originally Posted by tamlin

This is not a "tutorial". A tutorial is a teaching aid. This is a speeded-up video of someone working in Photoshop with a cheesy musical soundtrack. No instruction, no explanations, nothing.

tamlin why you are always bad talking my forum??? you say. very fas, this video french, this isnit montage.. ask u did you know photoshop??? pls you are good look .

**Tamlin** · 01-23-2007

fatih, my friend: I realize that you have spent a lot of time and effort finding and posting these links, and my criticisms are not aimed at you, just at the content of some of the material you have linked to. As a moderator, I think that it is one of my responsibilities to monitor the quality of sites and content that BioRUST links to, and I honestly feel that some (not all) of the videos you have linked to have no educational value for the reasons I have stated. I'm not the only one who has these opinions either, judging by some of the comments these videos have attracted on YouTube.

Of course, this also a forum for free speech, so anyone is welcome to disagree.

MoodsR4Cattle · 01-23-2007

I have to agree with Tamlin on this. It's not a tutorial and above that, it's showing a sloppy way to make a composite.

paulopires · 01-23-2007

This kind of videos (not tutorials) are just show off to impress people not to teach anything. I don't even think that Youtube is the proper place to post a serious or a professional tutorial. Youtube is a video broadcasting website.

turvas · 01-24-2007

I didn't even like the end outcome... But that may be just me.

But this is in no way a tutorial. The only thing it shows is: How to cut a boy in half (

), and how to erase.

SPAM:
Look over here (Graphicans Required!)

**Tamlin** · 01-24-2007

The video-maker has obviously never heard of non-destructive editing.